We are sorry to hear about UChicago. We assume that if you are reading this, you just got some bad news. You’re not alone. UChicago is annoyingly secretive about how many students they accept during their ED rounds, but with an overall acceptance rate that usually hovers around 4.5%, it is an extremely hard school to get into.
You might feel pretty dejected right now, but it is important to shake it off and prepare for the RD/ED2 round. Just because you didn’t get into UChicago does not mean that you aren’t a great candidate or that you won’t get into another amazing school. It is just going to take a little more work.
We work with students coming off an ED rejection every year. We help these students have successful RD rounds and get into top schools. So trust us when we say it is very possible to bounce back after not getting into UChicago. To help, we're breaking down some of our biggest tips for bouncing back after getting rejected from UChicago.
You don’t need to go it alone. Let us help you get into another amazing school. Reach out today!
STEP ONE: Take a Little Break
Eat that tub of ice cream or scream into the pillow. Do whatever you need to do to reset. A lot of students try to shove it all down and soldier on, but it’s okay to have feelings. It is good to get those feelings out. Give yourself a moment to de-stress and get into the right headspace.
If you are the kind of student who usually applies to UChicago, it means you are likely pretty type A. You are also probably pretty high-achieving and pretty new to rejection. Take a day or two to mourn, because once you have, the real work begins.
STEP TWO: Strategize
One of the best tools you have at your disposal is a balanced, dynamic, and strategic college list. It is time to review your college list to make sure it is working for you, not against you. There is a lot that goes into a truly strategic college list, but the minimum is having a mix of schools. You need to make sure your list has 3-4 reaches, 4-5 targets, and 2-3 safeties that you would be happy to attend.
You need to take some time to review your college list. The biggest mistake we see from students is categorizing schools randomly. If we ask you why something is a target, you need to be able to answer with some data. We recommend using tools like Naviance, looking up admissions statistics, and/or speaking with a counselor to ensure that your list is balanced.
You also need to make a plan for ED2 or at least heavily consider it. More schools now offer an ED2 option; at least one of the schools on your list likely does. It is an important tool for students coming off an ED rejection. If you are on the fence or need help choosing an appropriate ED2 school, we can help with that!
STEP THREE: Essays
Whenever a student comes to us after a rejection, we do a holistic review of their application. We find all kinds of places for improvement, but the biggest one is always the Common App essay.
If you are looking at top schools like UChicago, your essays are extremely important. Top schools receive more qualified applicants than they have space for, and a creative, eye-catching essay can be the difference between an admission and a rejection. We specialize in helping students write outstanding essays, so trust us when we say you probably need to rework your Common App essay. We know this is probably the last piece of advice you want to hear, but your Common App probably needs at least a good edit and, more likely, a rewrite.
This is a lot, and deadlines come up fast. It is part of the reason that we recommend working with a professional, but if you are dead set on going it alone, we suggest starting by reading our Official Guide to Writing the Common App Essay 2026-2027. We have a lot of tips in it for writing impressive Common App essays. Read it over and then reread your essay. Does it stack up? If not, time to get to work.
There is a lot to write over the next couple of weeks. Likely you have a lot of supplemental essays (especially if your college list has been retooled recently). Again, we can help and even have guides to school-specific supplements to help you craft high-quality essays. It is time to lock in and get your applications ready!
STEP FOUR: Get help
We have been saying it throughout this blog, but it bears repeating. Working with a professional is your best chance at getting into another top school during the RD round. We work with students every year to turn their application season around around after a rejection. We even offer a specific package for students in your exact situation: our “It’s Going to be Okay Package.”
Asking for help can be hard, but if you are ready to take that step, we are here for you.
Contact us today to take the right first step toward successful college applications.
